DELIVERING A PROGRAMME

Charity tools and information

WHY CHARITIES SHOULDN'T SHUDDER AT THE THOUGHT OF A GOVERNANCE REVIEW

In the wake of Kids Company’s closure, good governance is at the top of charity agendas, but what pitfalls should boards look out for?

GOOD GOVERNANCE

After the closure of Kids Company’s in 2015 and a string of more recent scandals in the sector, good governance is at the top of charity agendas, but what pitfalls should boards look out for?

1. You're always saying 'yes'

A good chair of trustees will assess the risks of adopting new technology.

We all need a cheerleader in our lives at some point and if anyone deserves one, it is the charity chief executive. Under pressure from cuts to funding and rising demand, our trusty chief executive needs to feel like the board’s chair is in their corner. However a good chair will achieve the right mix of support and challenge, and won’t be afraid to ask difficult and probing questions when the situation demands.

Imagine a chief executive is proposing, for instance, that the charity needs to invest heavily in a new technology platform that will underpin a different way of working with beneficiaries. A good chair and board will ask, “What are all the implications of this? What risks will we face by taking up new technology? Have you got what you need to make this work in practice?” By acting as a critical friend to the chief executive, the chair will ensure the thinking behind big decisions is robust enough to determine a successful outcome.
guardian-cheerleader
guardian-agenda

2.You’re sweating the small stuff

Ever heard of the Parkinson’s Law of Triviality or the Colour of the Bike Shed Phenomenon? This law states the time spent on any agenda item will be in inverse proportion to its cost and importance, on the basis that smaller matters are less intimidating to deal with than complex ones. Most boards slip into this mode at times despite the fact the board exists to address those 'do or die' issues that are central to the success of the charity.

One way to avoid this is by taking a firm grasp on the agenda. Every item contending for board attention should face the following questions

  • Is this a governance issue (as opposed to a management issue)?
  • Does it have policy or strategy implications?
  • Is it a priority for board time?

A further governance tool useful here is to organise your agenda items using four categories : for information; for approval; for discussion; for decision.

3. You’re looking inwards rather than preparing for new challenges

Avoiding questions like about how well the charity is achieving its mission is no good.

An effective board makes time and space to help the charity come up for air and thinks about the future as well as the now. The board needs time to work with the chief executive on making sense of these, in order that the charity can stay three steps ahead.

An away day is a tried and tested way of creating space for the board to remove themselves from day-to-day governance concerns and tackle some of the more fundamental questions that it is hard to get air time for in the normal board meetings. Questions like, “What policy changes are going to impact us in the next three years? What can we learn from last year’s work? Which direction are other charities in our space moving in? Are we still doing what we say we will, in terms of our mission?” Getting in an external facilitator to lead the day frees up the chief executive and senior staff, allowing them to focus on contributing to, rather than running, the meeting.

In summary, successful boards ask powerful questions, cheer and challenge in equal measure, and use their insight to think about the big picture for the future. Does that sound like your board? If not, now might just be the perfect opportunity to change that and begin that long-put off governance review.

guardian-navelgazing
group-chatting-CTAbanner

Can we help your organisation?

CHARITY ADVISORY

Our team of charity advisors work with charities that want to build their long-term resilience.

Find out how we can help

Related content

Charities


Whatever your size, we provide solutions for funding and financing your charity's needs.

Fundraising tools, tips and resources


Our fundraising tools, tips, and resources are here to help charities reach more donors, generate more income and impact more lives.

Resources for charity trustees


Good governance is essential for charities to be effective, accountable and sustainable. Explore our useful resources for charity trustees and leaders.