Our site places cookies on your device to give you the best experience. You can change your cookie settings at any time. Our Privacy Notice has more information on how to do this. I’m happy, please close this message

CAF: Charities Aid Foundation CAF: Charities Aid Foundation
Donate to a charity
Search

Search

Register
Log inClose CAF account drop-down menuLog in to your CAF account
CAF accountManage your:
CAF American Donor Fund
CAF Charity Account
CAF Charitable Trust
CAF Company Account
CAF Charity Dashboard
CAF Donate
CAF Give As You Earn

CAF BankManage your bank account
InvestmentsManage your CAF Investment Account
Search box
open menu close menu Menu Close
Donate to a charity
  • ◄COVID-19 Hub ►
  • ◄ I'm an individual ►
  • ◄ I'm a company ►
  • ◄ I'm a charity ►
  • ◄ CAF Bank
  • ◄ About us ►
  • For charities
  • For individuals
  • For philanthropists
  • For companies
 
  • ◄ Giving to charity > ►
  • ◄ Private Client Philanthropy > ►
  • ◄ Know more about giving > ►
  • ◄ Help and support > ►
  • ◄ Donate now > ►
  • ◄ Leave a lasting legacy
  • ◄ Grant making through us
  • ◄ Personal banking
  • ◄ Residential Development loans
  • ◄ For advisors
 
  • ◄ Set up a Payroll Giving scheme > ►
  • ◄ Grow your employee engagement > ►
  • ◄ Manage your corporate giving > ►
  • ◄ Manage your Partnership giving > ►
  • ◄ Connect with CAF Advisory > ►
  • ◄ Discover high impact grant making > ►
  • ◄ Explore CSR in your industry > ►
  • ◄ Application Zone
 
  • ◄ Everyday banking > ►
  • ◄ Savings > ►
  • ◄ Loans and social investment > ►
  • ◄ Investments > ►
  • ◄ Fundraising > ►
  • ◄ Your donations > ►
  • ◄ Grantmaking > ►
  • ◄ Strategic consultancy > ►
  • ◄ Legacies > ►
  • ◄ Charity tools and information > ►
  • ◄ Trustees and charity governance
 
  • ◄ Helping individuals give to charity
  • ◄ Making charities stronger
  • ◄ CAF Venturesome
  • ◄ About CAF Bank > ►
  • ◄ Governance > ►
  • ◄ Global Alliance > ►
  • ◄ Policy and Campaigns > ►
  • ◄ Research
  • ◄ CAF Blogs > ►
  • ◄ Work with us > ►
  • ◄ Media office
  • ◄ Experts and Events
  • ◄ Publications > ►
  • ◄ CAF Glossary of terms
  • ◄ Security centre > ►
 
  • ◄ Connecting you to charities
  • ◄ Open a giving account
  • ◄ Donate overseas
  • ◄ Payroll giving
  • ◄ Leave a lasting legacy
    • ◄ Manage your giving through us
    • ◄ CAF Charitable Trust
    • ◄ Paying Tax in the UK and US?
    • ◄ Become a social investor
    • ◄ Get expert consultancy
    • ◄ Meet the Team
      • ◄ Our tips, guides and information
      • ◄ Gift Aid
      • ◄ Tax efficient giving
      • ◄ The future of giving
        • ◄ Donating
        • ◄ CAF Charity Account
        • ◄ CAF Charitable Trust
        • ◄ Payroll giving
        • ◄ Expert consultancy
        • ◄ Grant making
          • ◄ Find a UK charity
            • ◄ CAF Give As You Earn
            • ◄ Apply
            • ◄ Grow your Payroll Giving scheme
            • ◄ Matching your employee donations
            • ◄ Meet our payroll givers
            • ◄ Get your Payroll Giving Quality Mark
            • ◄ 30 years of Payroll Giving
              • ◄ Start engaging employees with charitable giving
              • ◄ Find out more about Payroll Giving
              • ◄ Employee fundraising
              • ◄ Payroll Giving resource hub
              • ◄ Employee Engagement newsletter
                • ◄ CAF Company Account
                • ◄ Apply
                • ◄ Corporate giving for Partnerships
                • ◄ Manage your corporate grant making
                • ◄ Set up a corporate foundation
                • ◄ Give globally
                  • ◄ Bespoke giving account for Partnerships
                  • ◄ Spotlight on Professional Services
                    • ◄ Create high impact CSR programmes
                    • ◄ CSR in your industry
                    • ◄ Meet the team
                      • ◄ Impact through strategic grant making
                      • ◄ Meet the team
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Automotive
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Financial Services
                        • ◄ Spotlight on FMCG
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Partnerships
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Pharmaceuticals
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Professional Services
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Retail
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Technology
                        • ◄ Spotlight on Utilities
                        • ◄ For CSR and sustainability professionals
                        • ◄ Corporate Responsibility & Giving with Impact newsletter
                          • ◄ Everyday charity banking
                          • ◄ Online Banking
                          • ◄ CAF Bank Business card
                          • ◄ Taking card payments
                          • ◄ Bacs Bureau Service
                            • ◄ Borrowing options
                            • ◄ Secured loans with CAF Bank
                            • ◄ Social investment with CAF Venturesome
                              • ◄ Savings accounts
                              • ◄ Instant access savings account
                              • ◄ 60 Day Notice Account
                              • ◄ 90 Day Notice Account
                              • ◄ 12 Month Fixed Rate Saver
                              • ◄ 1 Year Fixed Term Account
                              • ◄ CAF Charity Deposit Platform
                                • ◄ Investment products
                                • ◄ Existing customer upgrade
                                • ◄ CAF Funds and prices
                                • ◄ Investment advice
                                • ◄ Start investing
                                  • ◄ Fundraising tips and advice
                                  • ◄ CAF Donate
                                  • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard
                                  • ◄ How to redeem CAF Charity Vouchers
                                  • ◄ CAF Donate Help
                                    • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard
                                    • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard Reporting
                                    • ◄ Sign up
                                    • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard Help
                                      • ◄ Grantmaking with CAF
                                      • ◄ Getting a grant
                                      • ◄ Contact us
                                        • ◄ Strategic consultancy for charities
                                        • ◄ Meet the Team
                                        • ◄ Contact us
                                          • ◄ Legacies and your charity
                                          • ◄ Contact us
                                          • ◄ Contact us
                                          • ◄ FAQs
                                          • ◄ Tools and guides
                                            • ◄ CAF insights
                                            • ◄ Fundraising webinars
                                            • ◄ Charity secret weapons
                                            • ◄ CAF Bulletin
                                              • ◄ CAF Bank Board Directors
                                              • ◄ CAF Bank Executives
                                              • ◄ Legal information
                                              • ◄ Regulatory information
                                              • ◄ CAF Bank Pillar 3 disclosures (.pdf opens in new window)
                                              • ◄ Complaints procedure
                                                • ◄ Our trustees
                                                • ◄ Our executive
                                                • ◄ Committees
                                                • ◄ Annual reports
                                                • ◄ Our Standards and Conduct Policy
                                                  • ◄ Case studies
                                                  • ◄ Contact us
                                                    • ◄ Policy and Campaigns
                                                    • ◄ Giving Tuesday
                                                    • ◄ Champion for charities
                                                    • ◄ Groundwork for growing giving
                                                    • ◄ Place based giving
                                                    • ◄ Future:Good
                                                      • ◄ Giving Thought blog
                                                      • ◄ CAF Venturesome blog
                                                      • ◄ Public Affairs blog
                                                      • ◄ Charities blog
                                                      • ◄ Research blog
                                                        • ◄ Development Fund
                                                        • ◄ Contact us
                                                        • ◄ SAR Volunteer Training Fund
                                                          • ◄ Vacancies
                                                          • ◄ Contact us
                                                            • ◄ 2019 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2018 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2017 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2016 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2015 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2014 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2013 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2012 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2011 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2010 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2009 publications
                                                            • ◄ 2008 publications
                                                            • ◄ Archive
                                                            • ◄ Contact us
                                                              • ◄ How do we help protect you
                                                              • ◄ How to keep yourself safe
                                                              • ◄ Be aware - types of threat
                                                              • ◄ How to spot a bank scam
                                                              • ◄ Seen something suspicious
                                                                open login menuclose login menu

                                                                Log in

                                                                CAF accountManage your:
                                                                CAF American Donor Fund
                                                                CAF Charity Account
                                                                CAF Charitable Trust
                                                                CAF Company Account
                                                                CAF Charity Dashboard
                                                                CAF Donate
                                                                CAF Give As You Earn
                                                                CAF BankManage your bank account
                                                                InvestmentsManage your CAF Investment Account
                                                                Register
                                                                1. Home
                                                                2. >
                                                                3. I'm an individual
                                                                4. >
                                                                5. Impact through philanthropy
                                                                6. >
                                                                7. Resource centre
                                                                8. >
                                                                9. Is there a right or a wrong way to give to charity?
                                                                • Share on Facebook
                                                                • Tweet this
                                                                • Share on LinkedIn
                                                                • Share CAF on WhatsApp
                                                                Aurelia

                                                                Aurelia Kassatly

                                                                Senior Manager Private Clients
                                                                Charities Aid Foundation

                                                                T: +44 (0) 3000 123 299
                                                                E: plannedgiving@cafonline.org

                                                                TwitterLogo-150px-x-150px@caf
                                                                 LinkedIn logo  Aurelia Kassatly

                                                                Is there a right or a wrong way to give to charity?

                                                                In our conversations with clients, we often encounter commonly held assumptions about giving that are often more nuanced than they seem.

                                                                Giving to charity can be a very personal matter, and quite a complex one, with minimal information on how to do it well.

                                                                This article marks the first in a series that we will be publishing exploring How to Give Well.  The series will address commonly held questions and inspire philanthropists to maximise their giving.

                                                                Myth one

                                                                Charities should have low overhead costs; all my donations should go directly to the cause

                                                                While it is certainly true that charities do not exist for themselves alone, enforcing low overhead costs (usually defined by the charity in how many pence in a pound does not go directly to their charitable work) actually restricts them and their ability to perform.

                                                                It can prevent charities from being able to monitor their work, design effective projects, and plan for the future.

                                                                Contrary to the conventional wisdom and public perception, studies have actually failed to find any correlation between low overhead costs and effectiveness.

                                                                Higher running costs can actually lead to better performance because this enables charities to prioritise learning, thinking and planning. We expect businesses to invest in themselves, but expect charities to do the opposite.

                                                                Using overheads as a proxy for effectiveness or efficiency is also only looked at in the context of charity.

                                                                For example, you wouldn’t want a car company to advertise the following: “90p of your pound goes directly to building the cars; only 10% of the cost goes towards testing, safety, and design.”

                                                                The truth is that it is important to do your due diligence on a charity and really do your homework. How are they tackling the issue that you care about? Are the leadership strong? Do they have good governance and do they report on what they have achieved? Is their information transparent?

                                                                Once you have reviewed and understood a charity well and how they are making a difference, supporting them with core funding rather than donations to specific projects will enable the charity to be much more nimble and effective: they will be able to use your gift where it is needed most. 

                                                                Myth two

                                                                Big/small charities are inefficient

                                                                The size of an organisation is not always a good indication of the quality of its work; the effectiveness of its programmes is a much better marker. At the same time, bigger charities can have advantages to smaller charities in terms of their power, recognition and economies of scale.

                                                                On the flipside, lots of small charities working on the same issue but separately can result in duplication of resources and effort that is also inefficient. Either way, by doing your research on the projects delivered by a charity, you are in a better place to decide where to donate money to. 

                                                                Myth three

                                                                Impact investing is more effective than traditional philanthropy

                                                                In some cases, impact-driven investments may be more effective but in others, charitable donations could be a better fit.

                                                                There are many different types of impact investing: anything from screening out ‘sin stocks’ to social investment like CAF Venturesome. It might be helpful to start with the idea that impact investing can have three types of impact: enterprise impact, financial impact, and non-monetary impact.

                                                                Enterprise impact is the social impact that a company has. In other words, how effective is that company at solving the social issue it seeks to address? And is that always more effective than directly donating to a charity? Not necessarily.

                                                                One example we can look at is anti-malaria nets.

                                                                Evidence suggests that distributing nets for free is much more effective than asking people to pay, since charging significantly reduces demand. Therefore, if you were investing in a social enterprise that sold beneficiaries anti-malaria nets you might actually have less impact than if you were donating that money to a charity that gave them out for free.

                                                                Financial impact is the impact that your investment has. If an impact investment opportunity gives market-rate returns, it could attract a socially neutral investor who is just looking for a good investment opportunity. The company would not have an issue raising capital, and so your donation could have more impact by going to an effective charity.

                                                                This leads us on to non-monetary impact, which is the skills, knowledge, and expertise that you can bring to a company that another investor could not. This type of impact means that you are likely to have more impact in private markets, where these types of resources are more needed. It might also mean that you can identify financially rewarding and impactful investment opportunities that other investors may not have come across. 

                                                                Again, we would recommend an approach of exploring your options. Impact investments can be an impactful choice in some areas, but not in all. To learn more about key definitions, concepts and how to determine when which method is more effective, tune into our impact investing webinar. 

                                                                Myth four

                                                                Organisations working directly with beneficiaries and communities are more effective than those working to affect systems level change

                                                                Both approaches can be effective. The question is how you perceive the problem you seek to address, and the change you want to see.

                                                                An organisation working directly with communities or beneficiaries can be very specific and targeted, and as a consequence may have a higher chance of success. It may also be easier to measure the impact of their programmes, since the link between the intervention, and the result, will be more direct.

                                                                On the other hand, organisations working to create a systemic change by necessity have to work with a wider range of stakeholders.

                                                                This type of work is harder to evidence because of the number of stakeholders involved, and the difficulties inherent in changing a system. 

                                                                However, if successful, it can also be far more impactful because it would result in a change in policy, or the provision of a service, to a whole group of people as opposed to a specific community. 

                                                                Myth five

                                                                I don’t have enough money to make a meaningful difference

                                                                The key determinant of the difference your donation will make is the difference that the charity you’re supporting makes.

                                                                While it’s true that the size of your donation can make a bigger or smaller difference to a charity’s finances depending on size of its budget, in terms of the impact your donation can have, it all comes down to the charity you choose.

                                                                If a charity runs really effective programmes, then your donation will make more of a difference than if it goes to a less effective charity.

                                                                You can find out how effective a charity’s programmes are by looking at the research and evidence into that particular approach.

                                                                Philanthropy services

                                                                Learn more about our range of first-class philanthropy services, including our tax-efficient, flexible giving vehicles.

                                                                Learn more 

                                                                Latest in philanthropy

                                                                Visit our philanthropy insights page for more from our team of experts. Subscribe to our philanthropy newsletter to get our latest news and insight into philanthropy, donating and impact investing.

                                                                Covid-19 philanthropy hub


                                                                Ways you can make a difference and support the most vulnerable through the pandemic.

                                                                Visit the hub ► 

                                                                Place-based philanthropy


                                                                We talk to Jim Minton, CEO of Toynbee Hall, about the opportunities and challenges of place-based philanthropy.

                                                                Listen to the podcast ► 

                                                                Philanthropy and behavioural biases


                                                                Learn how common behavioural biases can act as a barrier to supporting the causes we truly care about.

                                                                Read the article ► 
                                                                • Individuals
                                                                • Donate now
                                                                • CAF Charity Account
                                                                • CAF Charitable Trust
                                                                • CAF Charitable Legacy Service
                                                                • CAF American Donor Fund
                                                                • Giving to charity
                                                                • Your philanthropy
                                                                • Resource centre
                                                                • Companies
                                                                • CAF Give As You Earn
                                                                • CAF Company Account
                                                                • Corporate responsibility
                                                                • Engaging employees
                                                                • Corporate community
                                                                  investment
                                                                • Charities
                                                                • Everyday banking
                                                                • Borrowing
                                                                • Social investment
                                                                • Investments
                                                                • Fundraising services
                                                                • Expert Advice
                                                                • About us
                                                                • About CAF Bank
                                                                • Security Centre
                                                                • Media Office
                                                                • Our blogs
                                                                • Policy and Campaigns
                                                                • Research
                                                                • Experts and Events
                                                                • Publications
                                                                • Careers
                                                                CAF home
                                                                CAF on facebook
                                                                CAF on twitter
                                                                CAF on youtube
                                                                CAF on linkedin
                                                                CAF on Instagram
                                                                • Contact us
                                                                • Help
                                                                • Sitemap
                                                                • Accessibility
                                                                • Privacy

                                                                Modern Slavery Statement


                                                                Charities Aid Foundation © | Registered Charity Number 268369
                                                                25 Kings Hill Avenue, Kings Hill, West Malling, Kent ME19 4TA
                                                                10 St. Bride Street, London EC4A 4AD
                                                                Telephone: 03000 123 000