participatory grantmaking shutterstock_413960044

Giving Thought Podcast


What happens when philanthropic funders give away power as well as money? We explore the opportunities and challenges of participatory grantmaking

1 October 2019

In episode 57, we talk to Rose Longhurst about participation in philanthropy and her experience of radical approaches to grantmaking with Edge Fund (and others). Including:
  • What is Edge Fund, how did it come about, and what are its aims?
  • Where does Edge Fund fit in the wider landscape of participatory grantmaking?
  • How does its approach help to overcome some of the concerns about existing models of philanthropy? i.e. that they are undemocratic, that they fail to redistribute power, that they are incapable of addressing structural inequality?
  • Could more traditional funders replicate the Edge Fund approach? Which elements? And what would they need to change in order to make this happen?
  • There is a lot of focus on participatory approaches to grantmaking at the moment as part of the solution to the criticisms being leveled at philanthropy. How much of the rhetoric is reflected in reality?
  • Are there limits to participatory grantmaking? i.e. are there some situations in which it is better for expert funders to set aims and design programs?
  • Edge Fund itself has adopted a fairly radical, non-hierarchical structure. What is the rationale for this?
  • What are the strengths of non-hierarchical or de-centralised structures? What are the weaknesses or challenges?
  • Does a flat structure without clear leaders limit a non-hierarchical organisation’s ability to maintain sustained influence?
  • How do you prevent the emergence of hidden elites, or some groups prospering at the expense of others within a non-hierarchical network? (i.e. “Tyranny of Structurelessness” objections).

About the Giving Thought podcast

The Giving Thought podcast is an exploration of trends in global philanthropy and civil society.  Since launching in May 2017, the podcast has become recognised as an insightful and influential source of philanthropic debate. 

In each episode Rhodri Davies, Director of our Giving Thought Think Tank, and guests, take a contemporary issue in philanthropy and civil society and break it down into three manageable chunks, giving an overview of the extensive work they have done on the subject.  Episodes are also available free on iTunes and Libsyn.

Visit the Giving Thought podcast library

Rhodri Davies

Rhodri Davies

Head of Policy

Rhodri leads Giving Thought, our in-house think tank focusing on current and future issues affecting philanthropy and civil society. Rhodri has spent nearly a decade specialising in public policy around philanthropy and the work of charities, and has researched, written and presented on a wide range of topics. He has a first-class degree in Mathematics and Philosophy from the University of Oxford.   Read more about Rhodri



Take your philanthropy further

Read more about how the CAF Charitable Trust can benefit you in our handy information sheet

From philanthropy to purpose

Laura Dosanjh, Senior Corporate Advisor, explores the key corporate responsibility trends in the financial services industry.

Giving Thought blog

Our blog includes details about key issues affecting civil society, philanthropy, social investment and using new technologies for social good.