Our site places cookies on your device to give you the best experience. You can change your cookie settings at any time. Our Privacy Notice has more information on how to do this. I’m happy, please close this message

CAF: Charities Aid Foundation CAF: Charities Aid Foundation Skip to main content
Donate to a charity
Register
Log inClose CAF account drop-down menuLog in to your CAF account
CAF accountManage your:
CAF American Donor Fund
CAF Charity Account
CAF Charitable Trust
CAF Company Account
CAF Charity Dashboard
CAF Donate
CAF Give As You Earn

CAF BankManage your bank account
InvestmentsManage your CAF Investment Account
Search

Search

Search box
open menu close menu Menu Close
Donate to a charity
  • ◄COVID-19 Hub ►
  • ◄ I'm an individual ►
  • ◄ I'm a company ►
  • ◄ I'm a charity ►
  • ◄ CAF Bank ►
  • ◄ About us ►
  • For charities
  • For individuals
  • For philanthropists
  • For companies
 
  • ◄ Giving to charity > ►
  • ◄ Private Client Philanthropy > ►
  • ◄ Know more about giving > ►
  • ◄ Help and support > ►
  • ◄ Donate now > ►
  • ◄ Leave a lasting legacy
  • ◄ Grant making through us
  • ◄ Services for professional advisers
 
  • ◄ Employee giving > ►
  • ◄ Employee engagement > ►
  • ◄ Corporate giving > ►
  • ◄ Corporate and workplace fundraising
  • ◄ Impact advisory
  • ◄ Corporate grant making
  • ◄ Resource centre > ►
 
  • ◄ Adaptability resource hub
  • ◄ Everyday banking > ►
  • ◄ Savings > ►
  • ◄ Loans and social investment > ►
  • ◄ Investments > ►
  • ◄ Fundraising > ►
  • ◄ Your donations > ►
  • ◄ Grantmaking > ►
  • ◄ Strategic consultancy > ►
  • ◄ Legacies > ►
  • ◄ Trustees and charity governance
 
  • ◄ Everyday banking > ►
  • ◄ Loans > ►
  • ◄ Savings > ►
  • ◄ Help and support > ►
  • ◄ About CAF Bank > ►
  • ◄ Security centre > ►
 
  • ◄ Governance > ►
  • ◄ International > ►
  • ◄ Research and Commentary > ►
  • Careers
  • ◄ Press office > ►
  • Sustainability
 
  • ◄ Connecting you to charities
  • ◄ Open a giving account
  • ◄ Donate overseas
  • ◄ Payroll giving
  • ◄ Leave a lasting legacy
    • ◄ Manage your giving through us
    • ◄ CAF Charitable Trust
    • ◄ Paying Tax in the UK and US?
    • ◄ Become a social investor
    • ◄ Get expert consultancy
    • ◄ Meet the Team
      • ◄ Our tips, guides and information
      • ◄ Gift Aid
      • ◄ Tax efficient giving
      • ◄ The future of giving
        • ◄ Donating
        • ◄ CAF Charity Account
        • ◄ CAF Charitable Trust
        • ◄ Payroll giving
        • ◄ Expert consultancy
        • ◄ Grant making
          • ◄ Find a UK charity
            • ◄ CAF Give As You Earn
            • ◄ Grow your Payroll Giving scheme
            • ◄ Matching your employee donations
            • ◄ Get your Payroll Giving Quality Mark
              • ◄ Start engaging employees with charitable giving
              • ◄ Find out more about Payroll Giving
              • ◄ Payroll Giving resource hub
                • ◄ CAF Company Account
                • ◄ Manage your corporate grant making
                • ◄ Set up a corporate foundation
                  • ◄ Corporate giving insight
                  • ◄ Corporate giving case studies
                  • ◄ Get in touch
                    • ◄ Everyday charity banking
                    • ◄ Online banking
                    • ◄ CAF Bank Business card
                    • ◄ Taking card payments
                    • ◄ Bacs bureau service
                      • ◄ Borrowing options
                      • ◄ Secured loans with CAF Bank
                      • ◄ Social investment with CAF Venturesome
                        • ◄ Savings accounts
                        • ◄ Instant access savings account
                        • ◄ 60 Day Notice Account
                        • ◄ 90 Day Notice Account
                        • ◄ 12 Month Fixed Rate Saver
                        • ◄ 1 Year Fixed Term Account
                        • ◄ CAF Charity Deposit Platform
                          • ◄ Investment products
                          • ◄ Investment Knowledge Centre
                          • ◄ Getting started
                            • ◄ Fundraising tips and advice
                            • ◄ CAF Donate
                            • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard
                            • ◄ How to redeem CAF Charity Vouchers
                            • ◄ CAF Donate Help
                              • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard
                              • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard Reporting
                              • ◄ Sign up
                              • ◄ CAF Charity Dashboard Help
                                • ◄ Grantmaking with CAF
                                • ◄ Getting a grant
                                • ◄ Contact us
                                  • ◄ Supporting charity development and resilience
                                  • ◄ Meet the Team
                                  • ◄ Contact us
                                    • ◄ Legacies and your charity
                                    • ◄ Contact us
                                    • ◄ Contact us
                                    • ◄ FAQs
                                    • ◄ Tools and guides
                                      • ◄ Current account
                                      • ◄ Online banking
                                      • ◄ CAF Bank Business card
                                      • ◄ Taking card payments
                                      • ◄ Bacs bureau service
                                      • ◄ Interface for Third Party Providers
                                        • ◄ Secured loans
                                        • ◄ Loans for social housing projects
                                        • ◄ Social purpose development finance
                                        • ◄ Charity finance guides
                                        • ◄ Charity finance case studies
                                        • ◄ Intermediaries - Working with us
                                          • ◄ Instant access savings account
                                          • ◄ CAF savings options
                                            • ◄ We're here to help
                                            • ◄ Security centre
                                            • ◄ Protecting your money
                                            • ◄ Making a complaint
                                              • ◄ About us
                                              • ◄ CAF Bank Board of directors
                                              • ◄ CAF Bank Executives
                                              • ◄ Meet the team
                                              • ◄ Legal information
                                              • ◄ Regulatory information
                                              • ◄ CAF Bank Pillar 3 disclosure (.pdf opens in new window)
                                                • ◄ CAF Bank Board Directors
                                                • ◄ CAF Bank Executives
                                                • ◄ Legal information
                                                • ◄ Regulatory information
                                                • ◄ CAF Bank Pillar 3 disclosure (.pdf opens in new window)
                                                • ◄ Complaints procedure
                                                  • ◄ Our trustees
                                                  • ◄ Our executive
                                                  • ◄ Committees
                                                  • ◄ Annual reports
                                                  • ◄ Our Standards and Conduct Policy
                                                  • ◄ Legal information
                                                  • ◄ Regulatory information
                                                  • ◄ Complaints procedure
                                                    • ◄ Case studies
                                                    • ◄ Contact us
                                                      • ◄ Giving Tuesday
                                                      • ◄ Champion for charities
                                                      • ◄ Groundwork for growing giving
                                                      • ◄ Place based giving
                                                      • ◄ Future:Good
                                                        • ◄ Research
                                                        • ◄ Policy and Campaigns
                                                        • ◄ Publications
                                                        • ◄ Blogs
                                                          • ◄ Experts and Events
                                                            • ◄ Giving Thought blog
                                                            • ◄ CAF Venturesome blog
                                                            • ◄ Public Affairs blog
                                                            • ◄ Charities blog
                                                            • ◄ Research blog
                                                              • ◄ Development Fund
                                                              • ◄ Contact us
                                                              • ◄ SAR Volunteer Training Fund
                                                                • ◄ Vacancies
                                                                • ◄ Contact us
                                                                  • ◄ 2019 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2018 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2017 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2016 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2015 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2014 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2013 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2012 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2011 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2010 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2009 publications
                                                                  • ◄ 2008 publications
                                                                  • ◄ Archive
                                                                  • ◄ Contact us
                                                                    • ◄ How do we help protect you
                                                                    • ◄ How to keep yourself safe
                                                                    • ◄ Be aware - types of threat
                                                                    • ◄ How to spot a bank scam
                                                                    • ◄ Seen something suspicious
                                                                      open login menuclose login menu

                                                                      Log in

                                                                      CAF accountManage your:
                                                                      CAF American Donor Fund
                                                                      CAF Charity Account
                                                                      CAF Charitable Trust
                                                                      CAF Company Account
                                                                      CAF Charity Dashboard
                                                                      CAF Donate
                                                                      CAF Give As You Earn
                                                                      CAF BankManage your bank account
                                                                      InvestmentsManage your CAF Investment Account
                                                                      Register
                                                                      1. Home
                                                                      2. >
                                                                      3. About CAF
                                                                      4. >
                                                                      5. Blog Home
                                                                      6. >
                                                                      7. Giving thought
                                                                      8. >
                                                                      9. The future of doing good
                                                                      10. >
                                                                      11. Philanthropy, the Blockchain & the Internet of Things
                                                                      Rhodri Davies, Programme Leader, Giving Thought

                                                                      Rhodri Davies

                                                                      Head of Policy

                                                                      Charities Aid Foundation

                                                                      Twitter logo

                                                                      @Rhodri_H_Davies

                                                                      The role of giving

                                                                      PHILANTHROPY, BLOCKCHAIN AND THE INTERNET OF THINGS

                                                                      16 December 2015

                                                                      Today we launched a new discussion paper, “Giving Unchained: Philanthropy and the Blockchain”, which looks at the potential impact of new ‘blockchain technology’ on charitable giving and social action.

                                                                      This follows on from our Giving a Bit(Coin) paper earlier this year, which explored the possibilities of harnessing new forms of digital ‘cryptocurrency’ for philanthropy. The blockchain is a decentralised, shared public ledger that records ownership and transactions and is best known at the moment as the technology underpinning Bitcoin. However, many experts believe that the blockchain has far wider-reaching applications that could fundamentally affect the way we all live our lives. And the question at the heart of this paper is “what does that mean for philanthropy in the future?”

                                                                      I believe there are a number of intriguing possibilities, ranging from the pragmatic to the seemingly outlandish. In order to understand where these possibilities come from, it is necessary to understand a few of the key features of blockchain technology that are getting people in the technology and finance sectors so excited:

                                                                      1 RADICALLY REDUCED TRANSACTION COSTS

                                                                      The blockchain is decentralised. This means that it is not owned or operated by any one person or organisation, but rather shared between users, some or all of whom contribute processing power towards the calculations required to maintain the system. Likewise transactions on the blockchain do not require intermediation, as the infrastructure itself can be used to create things like 'Smart Contracts' which are computer protocols that record and enact contractual clauses between blockchain users.

                                                                      The net result is that the need for third parties is effectively removed, and thus transaction costs can be dramatically cut. In areas such as law and banking, this could have huge ramifications, which is presumably why so many big name firms are putting time and effort into exploring blockchain technology so that they can be ahead of the curve rather than behind it.

                                                                      From the point of view of philanthropy, a reduction in transaction costs when it comes to dealing with money and contracts could make it easier for charities to get more of the money they receive from donor’s through to the front line.

                                                                      2 INCREASED TRANSPARENCY

                                                                      The blockchain is by its nature entirely transparent (at least in the full-blown utopian version of the concept). This means that any user of the system can see exactly who owns what at any given time, and who has given what to whom. And when it comes to money; since cryptocurrency is non-fungible (i.e. each piece is unique so one piece cannot simple be exchanged for another), an individual donor would literally be able to track their donation right through a charity and out the other side.

                                                                      3 BLURRING THE LINES BETWEEN DIGITAL AND PHYSICAL

                                                                      There are ways of representing all kinds of assets, both financial and non-financial, on the blockchain. Some of these are even entirely intangible: for instance, there is a lot of interest in the music industry in whether the blockchain could revolutionise the way Intellectual Property is dealt with and people get credited for creative work. And at the other end of the spectrum from ephemeral assets like IP, physical assets might also be able to exist on the blockchain. There is a great deal of interest in whether blockchain technology can underpin the “Internet of Things”, made up of the growing number of smart, internet-enabled appliances such as energy meters, fridges and even houses.

                                                                      As a result, the blockchain may lead to the line between the online and physical world become increasingly blurred.

                                                                      So what will this mean for philanthropy and for charities? We explore this question in more detail in the paper, but here are three intriguing possibilities:

                                                                      4 ENHANCED TRUST

                                                                      Trust is one of the most important commodities for any charitable organisation, as they rely heavily on the trust and goodwill of their supporters and the wider public in order to raise funds and carry out their work. The blockchain offers real opportunities to bolster this trust.

                                                                      The removal of the need for third parties means that charities and non-profits would no longer have to rely on other institutions such as banks, lawyers and government bodies in the same way. Not only would this reduce their outgoings in terms of paying for transaction costs, but it could also help to avoid contamination when those other institutions are no trusted. For example, an international development charity operating in a part of the world where governance is poor and corruption is rife would surely welcome the possibility of being able to operate without having to deal with corrupt officials and organisations, as this is a major cause for concern amongst donors and supporters who fear that their money is being lost through corruption.

                                                                      The far greater degree of transparency offered by the blockchain could also play a key role in boosting trust. If people can see exactly where their donations are going, and exactly what an organisation is spending money on, then there is little room to hide. For those charities that are able to use this ‘radical transparency’ to demonstrate that they spend money relatively effectively, this could lead to increased support. However, there are also risks. As we pointed out in our report on cryptocurrency, the danger of such radical transparency is that without further efforts to educate donors about the way charities operate, it could simply lead to people making unreasonable demands about the way that their own donations are used.

                                                                      5 NEW TYPES OF ASSETS FOR PHILANTHROPY

                                                                      As highlighted above, the blockchain could act as a framework for a vast “Internet of Everything”, encompassing physical objects and intangible digital assets. On the assumption that any of these assets could be given away for charitable purposes, this opens up a potentially vast new array of resources for philanthropy. Coming back to the music IP example mentioned above, it might be possible to specify that a fraction of the IP for a particular piece of music could go to charity. This is a bit like the existing idea of a charity single, only the power of the blockchain in this instance is that it makes automated micro-payments on a vast scale feasible, and thus potentially overcomes the challenges presented by the rise of streaming services and the like.

                                                                      When it comes to physical assets, an intriguing thought occurs: the advent of an internet of things may spell the end of traditional notions of ownership because it makes more sense simply to share objects when temporary ownership can be transferred seamlessly via the blockchain. Hence people might start owning far less stuff. Could this be a problem for philanthropy, as donations of unwanted goods continue to be an important source of income for charitable organisations. Or, more radically, will it result in a shift of focus away from donations of spare objects towards donations of spare capacity in objects. i.e. Rather than donating a property to charity, you might donate use of the property during periods when it would otherwise be empty.

                                                                      6 THE BIRTH OF AI-PHILANTHROPY?

                                                                      The introduction of the idea of the Internet of Things and the value of spare capacity leads us to perhaps the most science fiction-like possibility: that in the future, smart appliances could emerge as an important new donor class.

                                                                      As well as physical capacity, spare processing capacity will also a valuable commodity within a blockchain-enabled Internet of Things. This means that any time your smart washing machine is not in use, for instance, it could be earning its keep by offering up its processing capacity either for the general maintenance of the system, or to other users who require extra capacity. As a result it could earn money. Some of this could be used to pay for maintenance and repair, but what if there is extra? Well, one option would be to stipulate that some or all of this money goes to charity.

                                                                      At first, this would almost certainly operate along the lines of existing initiatives such as “electronic rounding” schemes, which allow donors to round up card payments to the nearest pound and give the extra to charity, although in this case the donor would probably be able to choose their own charity. In time, however, as the ecosystem developed and became more sophisticated, it might make sense to implement “philanthropy smart contracts”, which take over responsibility for choosing charities based on performance data. Initially, the donor might still specify broad cause areas, but eventually it might be possible simply to empower the AI to give to the “best” charity based on analysis of what the most pressing needs are at that time and which organisations are most effective.

                                                                      This might sound far-fetched, and the technology is clearly not there yet (and perhaps more importantly, the data certainly isn’t); however the idea behind this sot of “AI Philanthropy” is already with us. Effective Altruism (or at least the pure form of it, not the increasingly-diluted form we are seeing now) argues that we should be totally agnostic about causes, and simply give to whatever is going to produce the “greatest good”. Since this has already been caricatured as philanthropy for robots, why not simply follow this to its logical conclusion and let the robots get on with it?

                                                                      As you can see, the implications of blockchain technology range from quite pragmatic solutions to problems we are dealing with right now to some more outlandish predictions about how things may be in the future. And, of course, as with any new technology where there is more than a dollop of hype, this might all come to nothing. However, the level of interest from big-name banks and technology companies suggests that there is something to blockchain technology. The choice for philanthropists and charities is whether to start thinking through the challenges and opportunities now, or risk getting left behind.

                                                                      RELATED CONTENT

                                                                      Our publications


                                                                      We produce research on charities and charitable giving to help charities understand the sector - and to thrive.

                                                                      Here's a list of our publications ► 

                                                                      Giving Thought blog


                                                                      Our blog includes details about key issues affecting civil society, philanthropy, social investment and using new technologies for social good.

                                                                      Read the blog ► 

                                                                      Charity Street III


                                                                      Charities play a vital role in our national life - but are we fully aware of how much good they do?

                                                                      Read the latest Charity Street report ► 
                                                                      • Individuals
                                                                      • Donate now
                                                                      • CAF Charity Account
                                                                      • CAF Charitable Trust
                                                                      • CAF Charitable Legacy Service
                                                                      • CAF American Donor Fund
                                                                      • Giving to charity
                                                                      • Your philanthropy
                                                                      • Resource centre
                                                                      • Companies
                                                                      • CAF Give As You Earn
                                                                      • CAF Company Account
                                                                      • Corporate responsibility
                                                                      • Engaging employees
                                                                      • Corporate community
                                                                        investment
                                                                      • Charities
                                                                      • Everyday banking
                                                                      • Borrowing
                                                                      • Social investment
                                                                      • Investments
                                                                      • Fundraising services
                                                                      • Expert Advice
                                                                      • About us
                                                                      • About CAF Bank
                                                                      • Security Centre
                                                                      • Media Office
                                                                      • Our blogs
                                                                      • Policy and Campaigns
                                                                      • Research
                                                                      • Experts and Events
                                                                      • Publications
                                                                      • Careers
                                                                      CAF home
                                                                      CAF on facebook
                                                                      CAF on twitter
                                                                      CAF on youtube
                                                                      CAF on linkedin
                                                                      CAF on Instagram
                                                                      • Contact us
                                                                      • Help
                                                                      • Sitemap
                                                                      • Accessibility
                                                                      • Privacy

                                                                      Modern Slavery Statement


                                                                      Charities Aid Foundation © | Registered Charity Number 268369
                                                                      25 Kings Hill Avenue, Kings Hill, West Malling, Kent ME19 4TA
                                                                      10 St. Bride Street, London EC4A 4AD
                                                                      Telephone: 03000 123 000