What is an investment strategy?
An investment strategy is a framework for deciding how assets should be invested to meet your organisation’s objectives. It brings together the desired return, investment timeframe, liquidity needs, tolerance and capacity for loss and any ethical or mission-related requirements.
The strongest strategy is not necessarily the one with the highest recent return. It is the one most likely to meet your organisation’s objectives at an acceptable level of risk and cost, while aligning with its mission. Asset allocation is an important part of this. It describes the long-term mix of investments, such as equities, fixed income, property, alternatives and cash, that you intend to hold.
For your charity, a good starting point is to consider your spending requirements, reserves, investment timeframe and capacity for risk, alongside responsible investment and mission considerations. Once you understand these objectives, you can start to consider the investment strategy itself.
What are the main types of investment strategy?
There are many different investment strategies. The examples below are some of the most common, and investors will often combine different approaches to suit their circumstances.
Growth
Growth focuses on assets expected to increase in value over time, usually through relatively high exposure to company shares or equities.
Income
Income focuses on investments that aim to generate dividends, interest or other distributions.
Growth and income
Growth and income seeks a combination of capital growth and income. For charities and endowments, this can help balance current spending needs with longer-term objectives.
Capital preservation
Capital preservation prioritises protecting capital from significant losses, generally through cash and lower-risk assets. It can be particularly relevant when the investment timeframe is short or liabilities are known.
Total return
Total return considers capital growth and income together rather than targeting one or the other. For example, an investor might choose to withdraw 3% of a portfolio each year, regardless of whether that return comes from income or capital growth.
What do passive and active management mean?
Market participants group similar assets together into indicies. The combined price movements can then provide an indication of how a particular market, region or investment style is performing.
The FTSE 100 is one example. It tracks the performance of 100 of the largest companies listed on the London Stock Exchange, with each company's influence on the index determined by its market value. Investors can use an index like this as a benchmark when assessing the performance of their own investments.
Passive, or index, management aims to track the performance of a chosen index rather than outperform it.
Active management involves selecting investments, usually with the aim of outperforming an index or another benchmark, such as inflation, or achieving a defined risk objective. The outcome will therefore depend on the decisions taken by the investment manager, as well as wider market conditions.
Passive investing does not rely on a manager selecting individual investments to try to outperform the market. This can generally be delivered at a lower cost than active management.
Depending on the index, passive funds can also provide broad exposure to a market, which may help diversify a portfolio. However, investors remain exposed to movements in the underlying market and to all the investments included in the index.
Some investors combine active funds with index-tracking investments. This can help balance cost with opportunities for active investment management.
What are strategic and tactical asset allocations?
Markets and the individual investments within them move all the time.
A strategic asset allocation is the long-term mix of asset types an investor intends to hold, such as equities, bonds, property, alternatives and cash. It reflects the combination that the investor believes is most appropriate for achieving their long-term objectives.
A tactical asset allocation involves temporarily moving away from these long-term allocations in response to changing market opportunities or risks.
For example, if a portfolio's strategic allocation to equities is 50%, an investment manager might temporarily increase or reduce that exposure if their view of market opportunities or risks changes. The portfolio may then move back towards its strategic allocation as those conditions change.
In practice, this means the actual asset allocation of a portfolio may move around its longer-term strategic targets over time.
Why use different asset types?
No single asset class consistently performs better than all the others.
An asset type that performs strongly in one period may perform less well in another. Predicting which asset class will perform best, and when that will change, is extremely difficult.
For this reason, many investors use a diversified, multi-asset approach that spreads their portfolio across several asset classes. Diversification can reduce dependence on the performance of any single market or type of investment, although it cannot remove investment risk altogether.
The choice of asset types and the amount invested in each will form the basis of your strategic asset allocation.
What if financial returns are not my only objective?
Most investors want their investments to generate growth, income or a combination of both. Increasingly, they are also considering how those returns are generated.
This can be particularly important for charities, where certain investments may not align with their mission, values or the expectations of donors and beneficiaries.
Investment strategies can include responsible or sustainable investment criteria. For example, a charity might limit or exclude exposure to companies or activities that conflict with its mission or investment policy.
Exclusion is not the only approach. Owning shares can also give investors voting rights and opportunities to engage with companies on issues that matter to them. Some investment managers use this stewardship role to encourage change rather than simply excluding a company from a portfolio.
Another option is impact investing, which intentionally seeks measurable environmental or social outcomes alongside a financial return.
Are there different styles of equity investing?
You may hear a number of different terms used to describe approaches to equity investing. Some of the more common styles include:
Growth investing
Growth investing targets companies expected to grow their earnings relatively quickly.
Value investing
Value investing looks for companies considered inexpensive compared with measures such as their earnings, assets or cash flow.
Quality investing
Quality investing seeks financially strong companies with reliable earnings and robust balance sheets.
Income investing
Income investing favours companies or securities that aim to generate relatively high or reliable income.
Momentum investing
Momentum investing focuses on investments displaying positive price or earnings trends.
Factor investing
Factor investing is a systematic approach that selects investments according to particular characteristics, or ‘factors’, such as value, quality, company size, momentum or volatility.
Different investment styles are likely to perform differently as economic and market conditions change.
They are also not alternatives to active or passive management. For example, a portfolio could use a passive global income fund or an actively managed value fund.
Creating a layered investment strategy for your charity
Developing an investment strategy involves a series of connected decisions. The following six areas can provide a useful framework for conversations with your trustees and investment advisers.
1. Start with your objectives
Be clear about what your investments need to achieve and over what timeframe.
For example: a charity might aim to generate sufficient long-term returns to support charitable expenditure while maintaining the real value of its assets.
2. Understand the risk you can take
Consider how much investment risk your charity can afford to take, including its ability to withstand short-term falls in value without affecting its activities.
For example: a charity with substantial reserves and a long investment timeframe may have a greater capacity for short-term fluctuations than one expecting to draw on its investments soon.
3. Choose your asset allocation
Decide on the long-term mix of equities, fixed income, property, cash and other assets that best reflects your objectives and approach to risk.
For example: a charity seeking long-term growth might hold a higher proportion of equities, while recognising the greater potential for short-term falls in value.
4. Decide how to invest
Consider how the strategy will be put into practice.
For example: this could involve active or passive management, a blend of both, a single multi-asset fund or several specialist investment managers.
5. Reflect your charity’s values
Consider whether your mission and values should influence what you invest in and how your investments are managed.
For example: your approach could include exclusions, sustainability themes, stewardship and engagement, or investments that seek a specific social or environmental impact.
6. Monitor and review
Agree how you will measure performance, assess whether the strategy remains suitable and how often it will be reviewed.
For example: you might assess returns against an appropriate market index, an inflation-based objective or other measures relevant to your charity. The aim is not necessarily to maximise returns, but to achieve your objectives within the level of risk and other parameters your charity has established.
Key takeaway
Investment strategy is not simply a choice between growth and income or active and passive management. It is a connected set of decisions covering your objectives, risk, asset allocation, implementation, responsible investment and ongoing monitoring.
For charities, a strong starting point is to establish clear objectives and understand the level of investment risk the organisation can afford to take. From there, trustees can compare suitable approaches based on potential return, risk, cost and alignment with the charity's mission.
Capital is at risk. The value and income from investments can fall as well as rise and are not guaranteed. Investors may get back less than they invest. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns.